Driving Trip - October 23, 2016

Note: click on the thumbnails for a larger image

This is the latest installment in the series of driving trips of myself and my former coworker John. For those familiar with these trips, we hope you enjoy our latest adventure. For those unfamiliar, we hope you'll tolerate my ramblings about nothing in particular. A SPV Rail Atlas of Ohio will come in handy for following along.

Our schedules this year seemingly could never jive to get a driving trip in. After rescheduling several times, we finally arrived on October 23rd for our next journey. Coming up with an itinerary with new places to see in our great state is getting more difficult. As Johnny Cash once sang, "I've been everywhere..." Well, we haven't been everywhere in Ohio, but just about every rail line in the state has been followed on one of our trips. The notable exception are some of the lines in far northeast Ohio which take several hours of doing nothing but driving to get there. So earlier in the week John and I discussed possible options and he mentioned a spot not far from the Honda plant in Marysville as a possible spot to see. So taking this as a spot to plan from, I came up with a trip which started us in Marysville.

I picked up John who was still groggy and in disbelief at the Buckeyes' lost to Penn State the night before. I went to bed at halftime knowing that if I stayed up I would get very little sleep so I didn't know the outcome until the morning. I noted to John that it sounded as if Q123 was coming up the CSX (ex-CR) Columbus Line Subdivision which is just a mile or so from his house. So we drove over and waited about five minutes to see Q123 fly by us. The Leonardsburg detector said "60 mph" which at least temporarily reassured John and I that CSX had not relegated this low traffic line to "branch status" and reduced the track speed.

CP 111
Q123 eastbound passes the signal at CP 111 at track speed on the CSX Columbus Line Sub.







We then made a bee line straight west from Delaware to Marysville, picking up another former Conrail route, the CSX Scottslawn Subdivision (ex T&OC) which runs from Columbus to Ridgeway where it becomes the Toledo Branch up to Toledo. We made a quick drive by the elevator in town which was absent of cars but did show signs of life. A little further north the line used to cross the CR (ex-Erie) Dayton Branch from Marion to Dayton at Peoria which has the railroad station name of Gar (more on this later). Today about three miles of the Erie main exists. To the west of the T&OC main is a couple miles of track that lead to the Honda Marysville plant, and to the east a mile or so piece of the main that leads to a large electric substation. This substation has increased in size since the last time I drove out here and it appears they use the rail line to move large pieces of equipment for the substation. 

Just north of this location is the line John mentioned to me - a branch line that extends from the T&OC and extends to Bellefontaine. I had driven up here several times but never noticed it. Just north of the County Road 125 road crossing you can see a tree line at an angle which denotes where the line used to exist. This line was abandoned by NYC so it has been gone for quite a while. We followed the line as closely as we could (the Honda plant was actually built on the right of way) until we arrived at East Liberty. John noted that he had seen photos of a depot here so we drove into town to take a look. Sure enough, a very precarious looking structure still sits today next to the RofW, as well as an old mill. The book "Railroad Depots of West Central Ohio" by Mark J. Camp notes that the depot was likely built in 1898 and that the rail line was abandoned in 1935 (though the "Sampling of Penn Central" book by Jerry Taylor says from Peoria to East Liberty was abandoned in 1937 and further west in 1932), so it is amazing the structure still stands. A local feline greeted us to her humble abode.

East Liberty, OH
A feed mill and old depot still stand in East Liberty. Both have seen better days.
East Liberty, OH
Here is a better view of where the NYC branch line ran between the two buildings. 
East Liberty, OH
The feed mill still has its sign in place despite being abandoned for many years.












East Liberty, OH
In spite being over 100 years old, the depot has weathered well being somewhat shielded.
East Liberty, OH
The southeast side of the depot is largely overgrown with vegetation. 
East Liberty, OH
Lots of junk, possibly from the old feed mill, litters the inside of the structure.









East Liberty, OH
The size of the tree next to the depot gives a clue as to how long the rail line has been gone.
East Liberty, OH
This friendly feline greeted us while we checked out the depot and feed mill. 











Across the street from the mill is this historical marker noting that John Garwood had built a mill near this location, and that the first post office here was known as Garwood's Mills. This probably explains where the railroad name "Gar" came from!

East Liberty, OH
Historical marker in East Liberty, OH about John Garwood.











From here westward State Route 292 basically is built on the RofW until where it splits just south of Zanesfield. The line curves to the south on the southeast side of town and parallels County Road 5 under Rt. 33 before it curves north into the rolling hills. This is an interesting area topographically as to the north is hilly while to the south is a nice wide valley where the Mad River flows. In spite of its ferocious name, the Mad River is nothing more than a wide creek in this area.

Instead of following the meandering RofW, we followed the Mad River valley into West Liberty. The old CCC&STL depot has been moved from the RofW to just off of Rt. 68 on the north side of town and is now a business. We drove through the grain elevator area which is the original alignment of this former CCC&STL line. The elevator was active but no cars were present. A little further west is the relocated main which is welded 127 lb. 1954 vintage rail. Here is the view:

West Liberty, OH
Looking north on the existing G&W (ex-CCC&STL) RofW at West Liberty, OH
West Liberty, OH
Looking south on the G&W RofW at West Liberty, OH.










On the north side of town we find where the old alignment of the RofW curves into town. The rail here is jointed 90 lb., 1915 vintage rail.

West Liberty, OH
The old CCC&STL alignment looking south toward West Liberty, OH
West Liberty, OH
The old CCC&STL alignment looking north toward Bellefontaine, OH 
West Liberty, OH
The grade crossing identification marker is from the Conrail era












Finally we arrive in Bellefontaine, a town whose name is often mispronounced by those not familiar with the area. No, it is not "bell fontaine" (fontaine as in Vince Fontaine, the DJ in the movie "Grease"), but rather "bell fountain." I know, how do you get "fountain" out of "fontaine", right? Anyway, there is no disputing that this is one of the more interesting railroad spots in Ohio today due to the relatively rugged terrain in the area. Bellefontaine is just west of the highest point in Ohio which officially is Campbell Hill at 1,550 ft. Eastbound trains on the CSX (ex-CR, CCC&STL) Mt. Victory Subdivision into Bellefontaine have to face the uphill grade of up to 0.75% as well as an almost 90 degree curve in town (I believe the westbound grade east of town is closer to 1%, however the line is fairly straight). 

The branch line we followed from Gar comes into Bellefontaine on the south end of town and meets what is left of a G&W (ex CR, CCC&StL) line from Springfield up to Bellefontaine at a spot called Gest. Here the track is welded 127 lb. 1952 vintage rail. We stopped here and took a few photos of the area which now serves as a trailhead. 

Gest, OH
Looking north on the existing G&W (ex-CCC&STL) RofW at Gest (just south of Bellefontaine, OH
Gest, OH
Looking south on the G&W RofW at Gest (just south of Bellefontaine, OH. A rail-trail is on the right side of the tracks.











On the west side of downtown Bellefontaine, all of the rail lines converged at the aforementioned sharp curve. A large station used to sit just north of the curve and two branch lines radiated to the northwest, one for the T&OC line we followed from Gar, and the other another former CCC&STL branch. Both show abandoned by Penn Central on the SPV map. BS Tower, a non-descript cinder block building slowly being taken over by vegetation, still stands at the former junction point at what is now known as CP 141. The first time I was here was in 1997 and the north-south track seen at Gest ended just south of the tower and still had an active NYC style signal even though the track was physically disconnected from anything else! Here are some photos of the area.

Bellefontaine, OH
Looking southwest in Bellefontaine, OH, BS Tower is in the center of the photo behind the trees. The north-south line came in between the tower and the building on the left. This was once a very busy place.
Bellefontaine, OH
Looking northwest in Bellefontaine, OH, the other T&OC and CCC&STL lines would have radiated north where the trees are on the left side. A large depot once stood where the trailer and containers are. 
Bellefontaine, OH
The trees around BS Tower are now taller than it! The north-south line went to the left of it.










As we drove into town we heard an eastbound train approaching. So we set up at the curve in town and waited... and waited... and waited. Did the train stop? Nope, it turns out it just was gravity doing its best to pull it back. We hear the squeal of the wheels and then seen the locomotives which were laying down as much sand as they had to give it traction. The sound was awesome, but John mused it would have sounded better if it had been a quartet of GP38s in Run 8 pulling the train (I concur!). Here are some photos of the struggling eastbound doing something between five and 10 mph. The third unit was not pulling so just the two lead units were doing all of the work.

Bellefontaine, OH
An eastbound CSX train struggles up the grade into Bellefontaine, OH. The 3rd unit was not online
Bellefontaine, OH
This photo shows the sand being released by the locomotive to help gain traction on the curve and uphill grade 
Bellefontaine, OH
After what seems like an eternity, the head end finally arrives at the road crossing. The train is moving at a jogger's pace through town.









After the rear end passed by, we heard the eastbound give a good roll by of a westbound. As loud as the eastbound was, the westbound sprints into town like a cat as it descends down the hill through town.

Bellefontaine, OH
A CSX westbound empty hopper train effortlessly glides through Bellefontaine, OH 












We pile into the car only to hear another meet, this time it is another eastbound struggling up the hill. Though not quite as slow as the first train, this one also wasn't moving very fast, either.

Bellefontaine, OH
Another CSX eastbound fights the grade and curve as it heads into Bellefontaine, OH
Bellefontaine, OH
A going away shot of the train as it heads toward the Rt. 47 overpass








Our trip plan had us now following the Indy Line west for a while which is what we did. By the way, the road crossings a couple miles west of Bellefontaine offer some of the most scenic views in the state. The terrain is hilly, the few curves are broad yielding beautiful photos of the RofW and surroundings. It reminds me of some of the scenery shown in the western states. We passed through the town of De Graff which had some cars spotted at the local agri-business. Little did we know at the time that the spur leading off the main is the original alignment of the RofW. It is well documented that the CCC&STL realigned the RofW further west in Sidney which is what yielded the infamous Big 4 bridge, however it appears a second realignment was done between De Graff and Sidney. The satellite maps show the old RofW hugging the south shore of the Great Miami River then diverging south back to the current alignment about 1/2 mile east of the diamond with the DT&I (now G&W). Eagle-eyed John spotted the old RofW as we came into Quincy. Our guess is that this was realigned around the same time as the work in Sidney.

From Quincy westward to Sidney, CSX reworked the signals to be bidirectional as part of the work done to put in the new connector between the Indy Line and the ex-B&O Toledo Subdivision. Just west of Quincy we hear someone calling signals and see this eastbound train at Pemberton.

Pemberton, OH
We catch this fast eastbound intermodal train at Pemberton, OH







We cris-crossed the line a few times before coasting into Sidney. We first payed homage to the massive Big 4 bridge built in 1923. I noted this on a previous trip write up that I once worked with a guy from Sidney who said he and his friends tee-peed the bridge in high school. Given the size of the bridge, that would have taken a boxcar of toilet paper to accomplish! We then drove into town looking for the original alignment of the RofW which we found on the north end of the downtown area. The old bridge abutments over Great Miami River are still in place. 

After driving the wrong way on a one-way street for a block (I apologize to the three drivers who honked at me, and to my passenger John), we found the old feed mill that has a marooned Western Maryland boxcar placed at the building. In spite not turning a wheel in probably decades, the car still looks pretty good.

We continued to follow the line west through towns much smaller than other cities or countries with the same name (Houston, Russia and Versailles). At Dawn (the city, not the time reference), we did a quick stop to look at the grain elevator at this location. John notes that the elevator appears in one (or more) railroad books. The elevator is still there but any remnants of a spur are long gone. 

Also while out here in rural Ohio, John mentions that almost every house has a Trump-Pence political sign. Little did we know that this was indicative of how the Ohio vote would go - rural Ohio heavily in favor of Trump and the large metro areas for Clinton. Who says the rural vote doesn't count!

Eventually we arrive in Ansonia where the CSX rail line used to cross a PC (ex-CCC&STL) north-south line. Today the PC line exists south of the CSX main where it heads toward Greenville. This line is operated by RJ Corman. CSX has a small yard just west of where the diamonds used to be and a transfer track exists in the southwest quadrant. The train station, in poor shape, also still stands where the diamonds used to be. While circling the area we hear an eastbound train approaching and watch it by.

Ansonia, OH
The view east at Ansonia, OH. The north-south PC line crossed where the depot is standing. The transfer track on the right heads to Greenville.
Ansonia, OH
An eastbound mixed freight heads east through Ansonia, OH. The class lights are a give-away that this is a former Conrail unit leading.









We then follow the PC line south. A few miles south is where this line crossed a branch of the CR (ex-PRR) Panhandle line at Meekers which was abandoned in the mid-1980s. Nothing more than a tree line suggests that this one busy line existed.

After grabbing an average tasting lunch at Burger King (our preferred location, Wendys, was jam-packed with the Sunday post-church crown), we drove into Greenville to check things out. Along with the RJ Corman line, Greenville used to also have another ex-PRR east-west branch and a B&O (ex-D&U) northwest-southeast line thread through town. The now RJ Corman line crossed both lines, first the B&O on the northwest side, and then the PRR line on the southwest side where the two lines look to have run on common trackage for a mile or so before splitting. The RJ Corman line ends where this common trackage once existed. A switch allows it to access a mile or so piece of the east-west PRR line that runs to the east side of town. The east end of the PRR line is also where RJ Corman's operations are. A nice depot still exists a little north of the aforementioned switch which is now occupied by an antique store. We stopped to take a few photos.

Greenville, OH
View looking north in Greenville, OH. The depot, now an antique shop, sits next to the RJ Corman main (ex-CCC&STL). 









After doing a reconnaissance through town, we then followed the B&O RofW northwest to Union City, Ohio / Union City, Indiana. There also used to be an interurban route which basically followed the same route to Union City. Here are a few photos of the trackage and tower.

Union City, IN
The view east at Union City, IN. The Ohio  - Indiana border is a block east of here. The land where the signal box is once had more tracks. 
Union City, IN
The tower in Union City, IN still stands but needs a new roof.









We then followed the Ohio/Indiana state line road north until we met up with another RJ Corman line (ex LE&W). The track, jointed 115 lb., 1965 vintage rail, has a thick coating of rust but appears to be in good shape. The line has been paved over on the state route road crossing and vegetation covers the track so it isn't passable in its current state. We take a few photos to document it.


west of Ft. Recovery, OH
Looking east into Ohio (the concrete post marks the state line), the line is overgrown. The track has been paved over at road crossing in the distance
west of Ft. Recovery, OH
Looking west into Indiana the line is rusty but looks to be in good shape











We then follow the line back eastward into Ft. Recovery which has a large grain elevator but no spur exists. A little further east we find a string of tank cars in storage. 

Moving east we arrive in Celina where the RJ Corman line once crossed the PC line mentioned in Ansonia, as well as a long gone CH&D north-south line. A few NKP style signals still stand along the RofW of the RJ Corman line. The last remnant of the north-south CH&D line used to serve a grain elevator on the north end of town but it appears the route has recently (within the past five years) been abandoned. Here is a view where the line snakes into town.

Celina, OH
Looking northeast toward Celina, a NKP style signal still stands at what used to be where a remnant of the CH&D breaks off to the north (the cars are on the CH&D alignment)
Celina, OH
Looking southwest away from Celina, the former LE&W line appears to be getting some use













We follow the RJ Corman line east which hugs the north shore of Grand Lake St. Marys. The lake is a man-made body of water created to support the canal system. It is a large lake which has developed a very large problem within the past 10 years - algae blooms. The water is now a dark green and swimming is not allowed. I won't get into the politics of the matter, but I will say that hopefully people will come to their senses and work together to fix the problem so that the locals can once again fully enjoy the lake.

Grand Lake St. Marys - St. Marys, OH
View of Grand Lake St. Marys on the eastern shore. The lake's algae bloom has resulted in fewer tourists visiting the area.










On the northeast side of the lake in St. Marys a wye and small yard exist. This is where RJ Corman stages cars for local industries including the former LE&W branch line that extends south from here to Minster. The depot for St. Marys also used to be at this location but was demolished several years ago. John and I decide to follow this line south. It looks like there used to be 3-4 customers in Minster which is the end of the line, but today only one customer remains. The track looks to get some use as the flangeways are still clear. Note the sharp curve in the photos below. John believes this is an add-on to the original end of the track.

Minster, OH
Here is the end of the line in Minster. The track makes a sharp curve and ends on the customer's property. A grain elevator just out of view on the immediate left may have been the original last customer, then this extension was built to serve the industry on the right.
Minster, OH
Looking north toward St. Marys the line runs along side a large building which used to have an active spur













Short on light, we headed back east crossing the CSX ex-B&O Toledo Sub. in Anna, then following the G&W ex-DT&I line from Maplewood down into Qunicy to pay homage to the large steel bridge over the Great Miami River. Here are some photos from April 21, 2010.

Quincy, OH

Quincy, OH











We then retraced our steps to confirm the sighting of the old RofW just east of Quincy. Back in De Graff, we see a CSX westbound over the state route 508 viaduct.



De Graff, OH
A CSX westbound heads into De Graff, OH. The original RofW breaks off just to the right of this photo.











With nothing else close we head back home after racking up another 365.6 miles on the car.

Questions, comments welcome!


Back to Trains Home index